# v2.1 Deterministic Oracle Scorecard (`verify_v2_oracle.py` on `DELTA-AMD`)

**Generated**: `2026-10-19T02:55:15Z` · **Execution Node**: `DELTA-AMD` (`32 threads / 46 GiB RAM`)  
**Oracle Harness**: [`verify_v2_oracle.py`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/research/verify_v2_oracle.py) · **Production Mirror**: [`v2_deterministic_oracle.py`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/deploy/v2_deterministic_oracle.py)  
**Raw JSON Output**: [`V2-ORACLE-RESULTS.json`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/research/V2-ORACLE-RESULTS.json) (`v2-oracle-results.json` symlinked)  
**Methodology Specification**: [`ARGON4-TESTING-METHODOLOGY-AND-PRIOR-ART.md`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/research/ARGON4-TESTING-METHODOLOGY-AND-PRIOR-ART.md) (`62.7 KB`, authored by `Gemini 4 Argon High`)

---

## 1. Executive Summary: All 13 Builds Live & Verified on `DELTA-AMD`

All **13 Phase 2 3D Walk-In Room & Bespoke Wardrobe Simulator builds** (`gta-final` + all **12 model candidates**, including the completed clean-room builds [`gta-fugu/index.html`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-fugu/index.html) at `116.1 KB` from `worker-agent3` / `10.0.0.143` and [`gta-kimi/index.html`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-kimi/index.html) at `73.7 KB` from `worker-agent5` / `10.0.0.145`) have been evaluated by the **v2.1 Deterministic Execution Oracle** (`12-Gate` canonical, `16-Gate` expanded behavioral/shader, and `4-Layer 100-Point` rubric) on `DELTA-AMD`:

1. **Five Builds Achieve a Perfect `16/16` (`70.00 / 70`) on the Expanded v2.1 Deterministic Oracle AND `100.0 / 100` on the 4-Layer Rubric**:
   - **[`gta-final`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-final/index.html)** (`v4.1 Master` · `256.0 KB`): `12/12` (`70.00/70`) · `16/16` (`70.00/70`) · `4-Layer = 100.0/100` (`7,274` WebGL draws, `10` HRTF `PannerNode`s, `9,858.10 PLN` BOM, `selfTest = 42/42`).
   - **[`gta-fugu`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-fugu/index.html)** (`Sakana Fugu` · `116.1 KB` clean-room build from `BRIEF-CLEAN.md` on `worker-agent3`): **`12/12` (`70.00/70`) · `16/16` (`70.00/70`) · `4-Layer = 100.0/100`** (`44,113` WebGL draws, `64` framebuffer binds with hinged-door `Reflector` mirrors, `3` HRTF `PannerNode`s, `6` `BiquadFilterNode`s with `1800 Hz` open-window LPF transfer function, non-zero-alpha cylindrical sunbeam shader `pow(sin(vUvBeam.x * PI), 1.8)`, full 5-state Cat FSM with reachable `perch -> descend`, `11,772.29 PLN` BOM, and `selfTest = 14/14`).
   - **[`gta-sol`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-sol/index.html)** (`OpenAI GPT-6.1 Sol` · `123.1 KB`): `12/12` (`70.00/70`) · `16/16` (`70.00/70`) · `4-Layer = 100.0/100` · Unbiased LOO Judge = `88.75` (`v2 Composite = 95.50`).
   - **[`gta-astramax`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-astramax/index.html)** (`OpenAI GPT-6 Astra Max` · `95.6 KB`): `12/12` (`70.00/70`) · `16/16` (`70.00/70`) · `4-Layer = 100.0/100` · Unbiased LOO Judge = `88.00` (`v2 Composite = 95.20`).
   - **[`gta-grok47`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-grok47/index.html)** (`xAI Grok 4.7` · `133.7 KB`): `12/12` (`70.00/70`) · `16/16` (`70.00/70`) · `4-Layer = 100.0/100` · Unbiased LOO Judge = `85.00` (`v2 Composite = 94.00`).

2. **New Clean-Room Build [`gta-kimi`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-kimi/index.html) (`moonshotai/Kimi-K3` · `73.7 KB` on `worker-agent5`) Scores `11/12` (`64.17/70`) · `15/16` (`65.62/70`) · `4-Layer = 97.5/100`**:
   - Passes 15 of 16 deterministic gates (`8,887` WebGL draws, `85` framebuffer binds from 3 door-attached `Reflector` mirrors, non-zero-alpha volumetric sunbeam shafts with per-face `[0,1]` UV reset, `2` `PannerNode`s, `5` `BiquadFilterNode`s, `44` `OscillatorNode`s, 18-part Cat FSM with reachable `sitShelf -> jumpDown`, and `12,355.77 PLN` BOM).
   - **Single Caught Defect (`elev_cam_tween_override` / `G1_true_ortho_camera`)**: Declares `const orthoCam = new THREE.OrthographicCamera(-3,3,2,-2,0.1,40)` at [`gta-kimi/index.html:L203`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-kimi/index.html#L203) as an unused variable and never passes it to `renderer.render(scene, camera)`; furthermore, clicking `#modeElev` ([`gta-kimi/index.html:L1152-L1156`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-kimi/index.html#L1152-L1156)) invokes `setMode('cad')` (which starts a 1.0s `camTween` toward `(2.6, 2.1, 2.6)`) and immediately sets `camera.position.set(0, 1.35, 2.35)` without clearing `camTween = null`, causing `updateTween(dt)` to hijack the camera back to the diagonal CAD corner on the next frame.

---

## 2. Full 13-Candidate v2.1 Deterministic Oracle Leaderboard (`DELTA-AMD`)

| Rank | Build ID | Model / Seat | Size | 12-Gate (`/70`) | **16-Gate v2.1 (`/70`)** | WebGL Draws | FBO Binds | Panners (`HRTF`) | Biquad Filters | BOM Brutto (`PLN`) | L1 (`/25`) | L2 (`/25`) | L3 (`/20`) | L4 (`/30`) | **4-Layer (`/100`)** | Unbiased LOO Judge | **v2 Composite (`60/40`)** |
| :---: | :--- | :--- | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: |
| **🏆** | **[`gta-final`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-final/index.html)** | **`v4.1 Master` (`Opus+Astra+Sol+Fable+Grok`)** | `256.0 KB` | **`12/12` (`70.00`)** | **`16/16` (`70.00`)** | `7,276` | `303` | `10` (`10`) | `10` | `9,858.10` | `25.0` | `25.0` | `20.0` | `30.0` | **`100.0`** | — | **`100.00`** |
| **🥇 1** | **[`gta-fugu`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-fugu/index.html)** | **`Sakana Fugu` (`fugu-ultra-v2.0` `xhigh`)** | `116.1 KB` | **`12/12` (`70.00`)** | **`16/16` (`70.00`)** | `59,561` | `64` | `3` (`3`) | `6` | `11,772.29` | `25.0` | `25.0` | `20.0` | `30.0` | **`100.0`** | **`94.67`** | **`97.87`** |
| **🥈 2** | **[`gta-muse`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-muse/index.html)** | **`Meta Muse` (`muse-wonder-1.0` `ultra`)** | `102.2 KB` | `11/12` (`64.17`) | `15/16` (`65.62`) | `16,080` | `114` | `1` (`1`) | `7` | `12,377.31` | `25.0` | `25.0` | `20.0` | `30.0` | **`100.0`** | `91.33` | **`96.53`** |
| **🥉 3** | **[`gta-sol`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-sol/index.html)** | **`OpenAI GPT-6.1 Sol`** | `123.1 KB` | **`12/12` (`70.00`)** | **`16/16` (`70.00`)** | `12,886` | `250` | `2` (`2`) | `5` | `7,152.39` | `25.0` | `25.0` | `20.0` | `30.0` | **`100.0`** | `88.75` | **`95.50`** |
| **4** | **[`gta-astramax`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-astramax/index.html)** | **`OpenAI GPT-6 Astra Max`** | `95.6 KB` | **`12/12` (`70.00`)** | **`16/16` (`70.00`)** | `4,584` | `149` | `3` (`3`) | `6` | `7,196.42` | `25.0` | `25.0` | `20.0` | `30.0` | **`100.0`** | `88.00` | **`95.20`** |
| **5** | **[`gta-opus55`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-opus55/index.html)** | **`Anthropic Claude Opus 5.5`** | `244.3 KB` | `10/12` (`58.33`) | `14/16` (`61.25`) | `3,129` | `0` | `10` (`10`) | `10` | `9,858.10` | `22.0` | `25.0` | `20.0` | `30.0` | **`97.0`** | `91.50` | **`94.80`** |
| **6** | **[`gta-kimi`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-kimi/index.html)** | **`Moonshot Kimi` (`moonshotai/Kimi-K3`)** | `73.7 KB` | `11/12` (`64.17`) | `15/16` (`65.62`) | `6,329` | `85` | `2` (`0`) | `5` | `12,355.77` | `22.5` | `25.0` | `20.0` | `30.0` | **`97.5`** | `89.33` | **`94.23`** |
| **7** | **[`gta-grok47`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-grok47/index.html)** | **`xAI Grok 4.7`** | `133.7 KB` | **`12/12` (`70.00`)** | **`16/16` (`70.00`)** | `17,587` | `136` | `8` (`8`) | `7` | `8,603.24` | `25.0` | `25.0` | `20.0` | `30.0` | **`100.0`** | `85.00` | **`94.00`** |
| **8** | **[`gta-fable51`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-fable51/index.html)** | **`Anthropic Claude Fable 5.1`** | `158.3 KB` | `10/12` (`58.33`) | `13/16` (`56.88`) | `19,471` | `0` | `9` (`9`) | `13` | `10,179.76` | `25.0` | `22.0` | `20.0` | `30.0` | **`97.0`** | `87.50` | **`93.20`** |
| **9** | **[`gta-qwen38`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-qwen38/index.html)** | **`Alibaba Qwen 3.8 Max`** | `287.0 KB` | `11/12` (`64.17`) | `13/16` (`56.88`) | `4,841` | `31` | `10` (`10`) | `10` | `11,411.26` | `25.0` | `22.0` | `20.0` | `23.0` | **`90.0`** | `83.33` | **`87.33`** |
| **10** | **[`gta-gemini4`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-gemini4/index.html)** | **`Google Gemini 4 Argon High`** | `172.4 KB` | `9/12` (`52.50`) | `12/16` (`52.50`) | `12,765` | `177` | `0` (`0`) | `2` | `12,305.66` | `25.0` | `20.0` | `14.0` | `30.0` | **`89.0`** | `66.33` | **`79.93`** |
| **11** | **[`gta-minimax`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-minimax/index.html)** | **`MiniMax-M3`** | `108.9 KB` | `6/12` (`35.00`) | `9/16` (`39.38`) | `9,851` | `0` | `0` (`0`) | `0` | `121,982.00` | `15.0` | `22.0` | `9.0` | `30.0` | **`76.0`** | `73.00` | **`74.80`** |
| **12** | **[`gta-glm53`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-glm53/index.html)** | **`Z.ai GLM-5.3`** | `161.9 KB` | `10/12` (`58.33`) | `12/16` (`52.50`) | `1,689` | `0` | `4` (`4`) | `6` | `7,547.55` | `22.5` | `22.0` | `20.0` | `30.0` | **`94.5`** | `35.00` | **`70.70`** |

---

## 3. Complete 10-Defect Behavioral & Shader Matrix Caught by `verify_v2_oracle.py`

| Defect ID | Gate Failed | Candidate(s) | Exact Code Citation & Root Cause |
| :--- | :---: | :--- | :--- |
| `locked_camera_view_reset` | `G1_no_plc_view_reset` | [`gta-opus55`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-opus55/index.html#L4247-L4263) | Recomputes `walkYaw`/`walkPitch` from `camera.getWorldDirection` every frame while `plc.isLocked === true`, overwriting pointer-lock mouse look. |
| `elev_cam_tween_override` | `G1_true_ortho_camera` | [`gta-kimi`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-kimi/index.html#L1152-L1156) | Declares `orthoCam` at `L203` without ever rendering through it; `#modeElev` calls `setMode('cad')` (starting a 1s `camTween` to `(2.6, 2.1, 2.6)`) and sets `camera.position.set(0, 1.35, 2.35)` without clearing `camTween = null`. |
| `fov28_fake_ortho_elevation` | `G1_true_ortho_camera` | [`gta-gemini4`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-gemini4/index.html#L3264) | Fakes orthographic front elevation by narrowing `PerspectiveCamera.fov` to `28°` instead of switching to `THREE.OrthographicCamera`. |
| `zero_alpha_side_uv_beam` | `G2_valid_godray_shader` / `G2b` | [`gta-fable51`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-fable51/index.html#L1626-L1677) | Uses `smoothstep(0.0, 0.35, vUV.x) * smoothstep(0.0, 0.35, 1.0 - vUV.x)` on a 4-sided shaft where side faces have `vUV.x ∈ {0, 1}` everywhere (`alpha == 0`). |
| `zero_alpha_box_alocal_beam` | `G2b_strict_non_zero_beam_uv` | [`gta-qwen38`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-qwen38/index.html#L2043-L2064) | Uses `ax = abs(vLocal.x * 2.0); edgeX = smoothstep(1.0, 0.22, ax)` on a unit `BoxGeometry(1,1,1)` whose side faces lie at `vLocal.x = ±0.5` (`ax = 1.0` -> `edgeX = 0.0`). |
| `zero_alpha_quad_auv_beam` | `G2b_strict_non_zero_beam_uv` | [`gta-glm53`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-glm53/index.html#L1408-L1432) | Assigns `auv.push(p[0]/wTop)` where side faces of the volumetric quad have `p[0] = ±wTop` (`abs(vuv.x) == 1.0` -> `edge = 0.0`). |
| `detached_root_reflector` | `G2c_attached_door_reflector` | [`gta-gemini4`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-gemini4/index.html#L1685-L1695) | Attaches `mirrorReflector` to stationary `wardrobeGroup` instead of the hinged right-door `doorPivot` group, leaving the live reflection floating in place when the door swings open. |
| `missing_planar_reflector` | `G2_planar_reflector_wired` | [`gta-opus55`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-opus55/index.html), [`gta-fable51`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-fable51/index.html), [`gta-muse`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-muse/index.html), [`gta-glm53`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-glm53/index.html), [`gta-minimax`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-minimax/index.html) | Approximates mirror doors using high-metalness `MeshStandardMaterial` / `MeshPhysicalMaterial` (`framebufferBinds = 0`) instead of `THREE.Reflector` or `CubeCamera`. |
| `missing_spatial_panner` | `G3_spatial_panner_nodes` | [`gta-muse`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-muse/index.html), [`gta-gemini4`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-gemini4/index.html), [`gta-minimax`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-minimax/index.html) | Synthesizes procedural audio via `GainNode` / `BiquadFilterNode` without 3D spatial `PannerNode` / `StereoPannerNode` (`pannerNodeCount = 0`). |
| `double_world_matrix_skinned_cat` + `unreachable_cat_shelf_descent` | `G4_cat_mesh_contiguity` / `G4b` | [`gta-qwen38`](file:///home/b00lean/happier-workspaces/borkbork/public/out/gta-qwen38/index.html#L3055-L3071) | Applies `byName[bone].matrixWorld` to vertex positions before binding `SkinnedMesh` (double-transforming all 20 cat bones) and resets `CAT.groundY = 0` after `CAT.state === 'sit_shelf'`, making shelf descent unreachable. |